Resonators are one of the oldest ways of acoustically treating a venue: So- there are centuries of proof that they work. There are also examples of ancient metallurgy, that have yet to be explained or replicated. ie: research Damascus Steel swords. Perhaps these guys hit on something authentic and were able to duplicate the technology and effects. Without experiencing something firsthand, I reserve judgement. But- that’s just me. (http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/dav/aaua/2013/00000099/00000001/art00010)
Moto_Man's Scam Of The Week
I thought that for the amusement of all (and principally my own), I would endeavor to scour the AudioGon ads and pick what appears to me in my purely unscientific way to be the "scam of the week," which typically represents overblown claims of wonderment coupled with a silly price. A couple of weeks ago, I highlighted some snake oil that I think will be difficult to beat . . . the $5800 Dalby D7 record clamp.
This week, there are a number of contestants ranging from the "Shun Mook Audio LP Clamp" yours for only $3,000. Here is what the seller claims about the Shun Mook Audio Clamp:
"This extra heavy century old ebony root which were immersed in the swamps of Africa has a unique power that no other wood possesses. The vibration generated by the diamond stylus in the vinyl groove besides inducing an electroflux through the phono-cartridge also excites the ebony molecules, causing it to resonate. This in turn is feed back through the stylus and is reproduced as expanded sound staging, enhanced separation, sharpened focus and enriched tonal balance of the music."
Century old ebony root that has received a "unique power" from the swamps of Africa? That gets excited by a phono cartridge's "electroflux?" Give me a break.
But in good conscience, the BS claims of the Shun Mook were already referenced in my prior thread on the Dalby D7, as deserving as this bit of nonsense is for "Scam of the Week," I will award that coveted distinction to . . .
The "HighEnd Novum PMR Premium MkII - Room Acoustic Resonator hand made in Germany" which is essentially a stepped bronze wok on a display stand, for $2,490. Now, as usual, I haven't heard the Room Acoustic Resonator. Maybe it is a miracle worker. Logic says it is total BS. Just read the numerous claims parroted by "reviewers."
"By overlaying the music with a full scale of multi-vocal overtones, more detailed sound is produced [by this bronze plate]. The music gets more momentum and energy, the presentation of the instruments is more realistic and more solid. The spatial imaging is increased in all directions. The result is again a natural and authentic sound experience with beautiful sounds."
Sure it does. The secret to this miracle plate? (1) Creation of a two-sand mold by means of a "primitive model"
(2) Heating the bronze alloy to about 1200 ° C (3) Casting of liquid metal in the form and the all-important (4)
Controlled cooling off the casting for the production of a fine crystalline structure of metal. It must be the production of that "fine crystalline structure of the metal" that overlays the music with a full scale of multi-vocal sounds. This screams for a legitimate double-blind test.
Those are just some of the reasons that I call out "HighEnd Novum PMR Premium MkII" as the Scam Of The Week.
Note: there is apparently a miniature version that is only $649. That is really too cheap to qualify as a "scam of the week," but it is possible that such a puny bronze plate must be used with the big daddy bronze plate to "tune" the music even further, which would probably qualify, LOL!
This week, there are a number of contestants ranging from the "Shun Mook Audio LP Clamp" yours for only $3,000. Here is what the seller claims about the Shun Mook Audio Clamp:
"This extra heavy century old ebony root which were immersed in the swamps of Africa has a unique power that no other wood possesses. The vibration generated by the diamond stylus in the vinyl groove besides inducing an electroflux through the phono-cartridge also excites the ebony molecules, causing it to resonate. This in turn is feed back through the stylus and is reproduced as expanded sound staging, enhanced separation, sharpened focus and enriched tonal balance of the music."
Century old ebony root that has received a "unique power" from the swamps of Africa? That gets excited by a phono cartridge's "electroflux?" Give me a break.
But in good conscience, the BS claims of the Shun Mook were already referenced in my prior thread on the Dalby D7, as deserving as this bit of nonsense is for "Scam of the Week," I will award that coveted distinction to . . .
The "HighEnd Novum PMR Premium MkII - Room Acoustic Resonator hand made in Germany" which is essentially a stepped bronze wok on a display stand, for $2,490. Now, as usual, I haven't heard the Room Acoustic Resonator. Maybe it is a miracle worker. Logic says it is total BS. Just read the numerous claims parroted by "reviewers."
"By overlaying the music with a full scale of multi-vocal overtones, more detailed sound is produced [by this bronze plate]. The music gets more momentum and energy, the presentation of the instruments is more realistic and more solid. The spatial imaging is increased in all directions. The result is again a natural and authentic sound experience with beautiful sounds."
Sure it does. The secret to this miracle plate? (1) Creation of a two-sand mold by means of a "primitive model"
(2) Heating the bronze alloy to about 1200 ° C (3) Casting of liquid metal in the form and the all-important (4)
Controlled cooling off the casting for the production of a fine crystalline structure of metal. It must be the production of that "fine crystalline structure of the metal" that overlays the music with a full scale of multi-vocal sounds. This screams for a legitimate double-blind test.
Those are just some of the reasons that I call out "HighEnd Novum PMR Premium MkII" as the Scam Of The Week.
Note: there is apparently a miniature version that is only $649. That is really too cheap to qualify as a "scam of the week," but it is possible that such a puny bronze plate must be used with the big daddy bronze plate to "tune" the music even further, which would probably qualify, LOL!
27 responses Add your response