VPI Scout 2 vs. Classic 1 vs MOFI ultradeck

mpomerantz-

I can speak directly about comparing the VPI Classic & MoFi ultra.

Had the opportunity to demo the Ultra in my system. I have a Classic that’s 6 years old.

Its automatically unfair because the MoFi comes with MM cart, and I have a decent LOMC.

IMO however, out of box the MoFi is certainly nicer looking and performs better than a price competitive Rega or Project. The supplied cart is nice, but you can hear its limitations,being a MM cart. I have a phonostage that can put a cart in its best light. If you get one, and already have a favorite. cart, buy it without the cart.

I think if I mounted my existing cart to the MoFi, it may sound close, but the VPI would audibly(subjectively) sound more convincing(perhaps the mass build?) Aesthetics , the VPI gets my vote. The MoFi still has a budget table look.

A used Classic/Scout w a decent cart IMO, is the better performer based on cost/sonics.

Thanks for the input.  It amazes me how much hype there is in the retail sector these days.

Have you any experience with the Scout 2?

Thanks again
MP

Do a search, there should  be owners giving perspective on Scout/Classic comparison.

"It amazes me how much hype there is in the retail sector these days."
Just like any market-sell the sizzle,not the steak!


I do believe the Classic design by sheer mass, may have a more positive effect on overall performance?
Also, it has the longer arm.

As tzh21y mentions,  the Technics also is solid. More accurate as far as speed stability goes. I don't care for the aesthetic of the Technics. 

The VPI speed  accuracy shortcoming isn't a deal breaker for me. VERY subtle, and you may even know notice till you use the ADS controller.

Make sure you are going to be happy with a unipivot tonearm. They take some getting used to and are more difficult to set up that a standard tonearm

Yes I have heard the same. I’m just not sure the mofi is as sonically pleasing 
thanks!