"Sounds like the input switch was in the wrong position of faint sound was coming through."
This is exactly what I was thinking.
Note: be patient as you test the various input pairs and the selector switch. It can be a little confusing - at least it was for me. For instance, viewed from the front, my LCR phono stage is at the 10 o'clock setting, even though the input is the furthest one to the left (looking from the back). And so on.