Why do some amplifiers throw a bigger soundstage than others?


Was watching a YouTube video comparing two Excellent class A amplifiers . the reviewer preferred, the one which threw a wider soundstage with the same set of speakers. Specified channel separation in db iis about the same in all quality amplifiers., so why does this happen?

rrm

When it comes to audio amplifiers, the concept of a "soundstage" refers to the spatial representation and imaging of sound within a recording. It's the ability of an audio system to create a three-dimensional sonic image, where instruments and voices are perceived as coming from specific locations within the soundstage.

The perception of a larger soundstage can be influenced by various factors, including the design and characteristics of the amplifier itself. Here are a few reasons why some amplifiers may be perceived to have a bigger soundstage:

1. Power and dynamics: Amplifiers with higher power output and better dynamic range can reproduce music with greater energy and impact. This can result in a more expansive and immersive soundstage, as the increased power allows for better control over the speakers and the ability to accurately reproduce subtle details in the recording.

2. Low distortion: Amplifiers with low levels of distortion can provide a cleaner and more accurate representation of the audio signal. Distortion can smear the soundstage and reduce the clarity and separation of instruments and voices within the recording. By minimizing distortion, an amplifier can help create a more spacious and defined soundstage.

3. Channel separation: Good channel separation is essential for creating a wide and precise soundstage. It refers to the ability of an amplifier to keep the left and right audio channels separate, preventing crosstalk and ensuring accurate imaging. Amplifiers with excellent channel separation can help localize sounds more precisely and create a wider sense of space.

4. Transient response: The transient response of an amplifier refers to its ability to accurately reproduce sudden changes in the music, such as the attack and decay of musical notes. Amplifiers with fast and precise transient response can provide better imaging and localization, which contributes to a more expansive soundstage.

5. Room acoustics: The soundstage of an audio system is not solely determined by the amplifier itself but is also influenced by the listening environment. Factors like room size, shape, and acoustic treatment can impact the perception of the soundstage. However, a well-designed amplifier can complement the room acoustics and maximize the potential of the soundstage.

It's important to note that the contribution of the amplifier to the overall soundstage is just one piece of the puzzle. Other components in the audio chain, such as speakers, source material, and recording quality, also play significant roles in shaping the perceived soundstage. Therefore, achieving a larger soundstage is a combination of careful system design and optimization across all components.

Mapman is right because he exposed almost all factors..

i will add vibrations resonance control and the room/house electrical grid factors...

The main factor , save if the design of the gear is not very good, room acoustic controls... For sure it takes a good amplifier but it is one of many factors...

With the same relatively good amplifier i can transform completely the soundstage impression by modifying the room... I did it by the way... It is not an opinion but a fact...

My soundstage was filling completely the room around me and beside me with no sound coming from the speakers plane ...the main fact was not my choice of amplifier , even if the amplifier must be minimally good for sure otherwise nothing work well , but the main factors was acoustics understanding and disposition of many devices of all kind to do the job ( resonators, and others devices)

But atmasphere explained why some amplifier do a good job and are better than others for the soundstage and timbre...

At the end it will be acoustic room disposition though the main factor...

I like the way a seasoned amp maker put it:

Competently designed speakers can sound different from each other.

Competently designed amplifiers can sound different from each other, but less so.

Two things: lack of phase shift and aural effects having to do with the 2nd and 3rd harmonics, the latter of which can make an amp seem more detailed and spacious.

Thanks @atmasphere

The perception of a larger soundstage can be influenced by various factors, including the design and characteristics of the amplifier itself. Here are a few reasons why some amplifiers may be perceived to have a bigger soundstage:

1. Power and dynamics
2. Low distortion
3. Channel separation
4. Transient response
5. Room acoustics

Thanks @mapman

Isn’t it nice to get straightforward and technical answers rather than responses that it’s user-error or placebo effect? Lazy thinking which blames listeners first is so enervating.

+1 @hilde45 @atmasphere @mapman @mahgister

Thank you all for distilling things properly. These important factors are often overlooked and/or usurped by either hyperbole or oscilloscopes.