I find that engaging in the ‘Which is better? Streaming vs CDP? ‘has gotten rather pointless. Both technologies are mature. They are both capable of excellent sound. It comes down to features. Does the convenience of streaming outweigh some of its disadvantages? Do you still have an attachment to Physical Media.
I primarily listen to Classical Music. I thought that I would burn my collection of thousands of CDs to my server and free up tons of space. I was happy with the SQ of my ripped discs and enjoyed the convenience of auditioning new releases from streaming services.
It turns out that there isn’t a single software program that I’ve encountered-and I’ve tried many, including Roon-that can organize Classical Music. I can find CDs faster on my shelf than in the media libraries. Also many of these recordings were not big sellers-perhaps 20,000 units- and some are recordings dating back decades. The availability of these recordings in the services such as Qobuz is spotty as their availability ebbs and recedes.
So for me CDs will be part of the equation until I croak and unfortunately my heirs will be stuck disposing of them. Sometimes I just feel like parking in the recliner and using my server to access the ones that it can find