Should speakers be upgraded before preamp and amplifiers?
On a two year plan to upgrade my system. Wanting opinions on what to do first, looking to spend $10-15k, listening room 14x 30 x 8. Currently have Von Schweikert VR-2 speakers Sansui 9090db receiver Pioneer PL-a35 turntable. Would like to try a system with tube preamp. Thanks
We addressed speakers and amps, but after they’re sorted out, your turntable might be a sonic bottleneck. So agree with @dekaythat an upgrading to a reasonably priced phono stage a great idea.
If possible, listen to different systems to define the sonic and physical attributes that work for you. Then narrow your search to components within your budget that have those attributes. You'll have your road map. I would go after the sources and el electronics. Then the speakers and the room will be the limiting factors.
In the end, you gotta ask yourself, "do I want to be able to listen to my system for hours at a time and look forward to next time? The presentation of a loudspeaker and how it interacts with a specific person is the basis to evolve.
Everyone is full of advice on how to spend your money. Forget that advice. Start with an assessment of what you currently have. What do you like about it? What are the positive things about it that you want to retain in your new system? What do you hear that you would like to improve upon? What music sources are you most interested in? Vinyl? CDs? Streaming? etc. Once you have a clear idea of what you want to achieve, your shopping list will be easier to start to sort out. Be flexible. You might start out thinking that you want a tube preamp, but discover that you can achieve your objectives with a class D integrated, and if you do something like that you can afford much better speakers. I say this because in my primary system the electronics are all top of the line Conrad-Johnson tube, whereas I just assembled a new system for my second home and bought a Marantz P10 on close out for a song that sounds quite good even in comparison. I did not start out thinking I would end up with this amp, but by knowing what my goals were for the sound sought that is how it worked out. Do a lot of soul searching. Start with listening very carefully to what you have now. Remember, what do you like, what do you want to improve? I spent 6 months getting inside my own head on that stuff first.
That’s quite a time capsule you have. I had the same receiver with a PL-19 with JBL 100’s in 1978. That being said, ans mentioned above find the speakers you like and then choose an amp that compliments them. At your price point I would consider a new Technics TT and a Bluesound streamer. If you buy an integrated amp and speakers used you would be able to assemble a better sounding system. Later you could get a separate phono stage and upgrade to a better DAC. You can spin your vinyl and stream internet radio without buying a music subscription. But you need to visit stores or a trade show to find what you like. Happy hunting , Mike.
Absolutely speakers first. Find some you really like the sound of at resellers and friends. Notice what they’re paired with at careful listening can shape your component decisions also. One of the things to recall about speakers is that bookshellf speakers with stands take up about as much room as floor standers. Bass reproduction desires could steer you towards floor standers too.
Speakers first. You want to mate them with complementary components. While given whatever speakers you choose it is most important to mate with appropriate amplification... the preamp can maters. For instance if you get hyper detailed speakers... you don’t want a lean hyper detailed preamp... mating is very important.
Tube preamp, definitely. This is the component that is really largely influential on the musicality and naturalness... get this one wrong and everything will not sound right. So choose a good tube preamp.
I try to follow this for next purchase decisions. Where am I at with everything else and what am I looking to accomplish? Just a different flavor or are there still basic needs to cover.
OK, let me ask...why do you want to upgrade? What do you want to achieve sound-wise? What type of music are you drawn to? Format? Do you have a good dealer nearby where you can demo different pieces of equipment to see what each brings to the equation?. I think you need to start the journey of identifying what it is that you want to achieve and then begin putting the pieces together. Speakers bring a lot of character to the overall presentation, but then the source has a lot to do with it as the speakers present what is presented to it, even the interconnects and cables can have a lot to do with it. So, having a good idea of what it is that is important to you sonically is a good starting point. You cant figure how to get there unless you have a good idea of where 'there" is.
Maybe look at integrated amps from McIntosh. You will want to buy an upgraded amp then align with your speakers. As an example; if your amp has 200 watts, then buy your speakers that will match at 200 watts maximum. Other wise you could end up with an amp at 200 watts and your speakers at only 150 amps.
@daveoman Could I suggest you start with your room. The dimensions you have stated do not produce good results from a couple of acoustic calculators I use. They say the room is half the equation to a great system. Just a thought. Cheers.
Oh dear. You have it backwards. Improve your turntable to a Technics SL1300G/Nagaoka MP500 and replace the old receiver with something like a VAC integrated for $7k all in, and you won’t need to replace the Von Schweikerts.
I would assemble a completely new system. Yes, first choose the speakers. $15k is not little, especially if you buy used pieces, at least some of them.
What do you want from your system? What is missing right now? You have new speakers and vintage electronics. Do you want to stay with vintage?
Room sounding ok? Otherwise this is where you get the biggest difference.
You seem to be a vinyl person. Depending on cartridge, I would consider a dedicated phono-stage and see where that gets you. Maybe also vinyl cleaning equipment (vacuum and/or ultrasonic). my 2c.
You must have a verified phone number and physical address in order to post in the Audiogon Forums. Please return to Audiogon.com and complete this step. If you have any questions please contact Support.