@larryi +6
Mike
Simple question, probably stupid
Is it necessary to have sound (music or white noise) playing through the speakers when burning in new tubes? I have bought a matched quad of Shuguang KT88 Z Black Treasure tubes to compare with my current Gold Lion KT88 and Tung-Sol KT120 tubes in a Rogue Stereo 90 amp. Reviews of the Shuguang tubes indicate that they need around 200 hours of burn in to reach their true potential but I am not looking forward to having to listen to 200 hours of crap sound.
@larryi +6 Mike |
I guess I’m lucky. I’ve never had tubes sound bad right out of box. Having said that, some tubes get better in a few hour. It’s not hearing bias or my ears adjusting. I usually by an extra set when buying tubes,( just in case ) and have A/B them after a few hours and they do sound better. All the best. |
+1 @larryi Just listen to your system, you’re wasting the hours on your tubes. |
I have always found that tubes do get better with "burn in time". As others have said and as Brent Jesse who is my go to for NOS tubes says you have 2 options: leave the amps on for the desired period of time, no signal needed or just burn them in by using them. I've generally done the latter as I really enjoy hearing how they change. |
Mho, there are no stupid questions, really. I've viewed 'break-in' as something that should be done with ss as well; 'conditioning' to a life of service... I recall when for vehicles of any sort called for a break-in period of +/- miles before one did 'pedal to the metal', to let all the mechanicals 'seat 'n seal' properly. How about a 'structured approach'? 10 hr. 'idle'; on with no signal....just warming up. That allows for some degree of 'grats', even if not 'immediate'.... ;) Can't hurt, might do the thing that's suggested without having to 'pause the Cause' for 100... ;) Enjoy the 'arrival', J |
Hello mazian. It is important not to operate a tube amp using output transformers without a load on the output terminals. (As opposed to solid state amps which don't care about having speakers connected.) The advice of others responding before me is quite useful. So if you decide to play music while putting hours on the tubes (not really necessary, as they won't sound "bad") substitute a suitable resistor for the speakers if you don't wish to hear whatever is playing. I encourage to play your favorite tunes and enjoy the music. |
With new tubes from China, Russia 50 hours is pretty close to runin and not anywhere close to NOS tubes which take 2 x to settle in any last much longer the tube standards were far better ,such as 98+ % vacuum vs 92-94% today , the metal recipe quality is not there back in the 50-60s grids many times inspected every 100 pcs now many every 3000. the new Gold lions they bough5 the name ,not even close to the originals. Tungsol made the Best 6550- today called kt88, even GE much better or Japanese made from the 70s. That’s why I only buy or have custom built by RaduTarta SET or transformer ,choke coupled preamplifier ,for quality throughout no China or Russian Anything. Emission labs makes nice tubes as well as Western Electric 300B orTaks from Japan. |
Thank you to all those who read, understood and responded to my simple question and to all those who chose to answer a completely different question ie do tubes need to be burnt in? With regard to that latter issue, as it has been raised, I might as well add my 2 cents worth. If Brent Jesse, a guy who has extensive experience with almost all types and brands of tubes, says they need burn in then in my view they need burn in. If anyone on this site claims they have more experience than Brent Jesse please raise your hand. Also why would all reviewers of the Shuguang tube, who generally responded favourably, make a point that they need an extremely long burn in time? In my experience over many years (too many years ) I have found that some tubes need about 10 hours burn in and others much longer. I have never encountered a tube that needs 200 hours so when I start to use the Black Treasures I guess I will find out. |
+1 @larryi Just inset your tubes press play and enjoy the sound steadily improving. |
Good question.
I have found the majority of tube burn in happens very quickly… about 10 hours. Then the amount of change is vastly smaller.
I would get the first ten hours on them. Then enjoy listening. However, obviously if they sound too edgy and not enjoyable… burn in until they do.
While you are at it while listening, see if you hear a lot of change. I’d love to hear your observations along the way. |
Good question, not stupid at all on, no signal needed, 60 hrs brent jesse advises burning new tubes in for 60 hours, before listening, then judge how they sound. ........................................ my last order, I had working tubes (unmatched, but wanted a new matched pair of 6sn7’s that did not look absolutely identical to my adjacent 6sl7 (I had blown one I somehow put in the wrong socket position after testing them). Received the new tubes, compared to existing some magic was gone, burnt in 60 hrs, still didn’t like them, returned. bought a matched set that cost less, full credit, and refund for the price difference balance due. I paid shipping to return them of course. Magic returned! That’s the reason I recommend buying from Brent.
|
This is a verbatim quote, from a letter Brent Jessee sends, whenever one buys valves from him: "CARE AND FEEDING OF NEW TUBES: BREAK-IN Preamp tubes especially benefit from a good break-in. This period may vary widely, but NOS vintage tubes usually need at least 48 hours of use, sometimes up to 100 hours. New current production tubes need 24-48 hours typically. Good break-in can be accomplished by either leaving your tube unit turned on in a no-signal condition for 2 days, or you can just enjoy the tubes for several hours each evening and they will be broken in after several weeks. New tubes, especially NOS vintage tubes, may sound a bit edgy at first, but after the break-in period will mellow out and sound wonderful." |