Speaker recommendations 10 to 30k and no beryllium
Looking to upgrade from paradigm sigs8v2. Willing to buy new or used. My room is 12x16x8 ft. Looking for floor standers. Trying to get away from beryllium in case of kids accidentally damage them.
I have provided my thoughts about them in the Yamaha NS5000 thread.Wonderful sounding things with the real bonus that they are an easy speaker to drive so that opens up the opportunity to drive them with purist moderately powered tube or class A SS amplifiers.Whereas many of the alternatives llike Focal,Magico,Wilson,B&W etc dip down to between 2-3 ohms so are ridiculously amplifier hostile. .
Told you the Yamaha NS 5000s are the real deal.At least for anybody who has a musical soul and who has some insight into how acoustic music and voices sound.
Reality is you need to begin isolating variables in order to get anywhere. The room has a HUGE influence on the end result. Chances are a less than ideal sounding audition/system can be set up to sound way better in your home. The reverse is also true, hearing something amazing at a Dealer will very rarely translate to the same experience at home without considerable effort and expense. Buy something that excites you and begin the journey with that in your home.
You can, go to My Kind of Music. In all honesty it seems like you're more interested in talking and writing about speakers than you are actually buying something. No audition will ever be ideal nor translate exactly to your listening room. It is much easier to make a $20K system sound great than it is a $100K one.
@prof might certainly be one of those situations where there is an initial big wow factor but the more you listen the more you might get fatigued. I wonder if this can be tamed with tubes though.
If John Paul Jones song Bass ’n’ Drums at unhealthy levels are in your taste the speaker for you are the Quested v3110. An active monster for pros. Naturally they play everything you give them with the same self confidence. Yamaha NS 5000 may be a interesting contender.
I auditioned the Paradigm Persona speakers twice, in two locations, and though I found some aspects impressive, each time I found myself getting fatigued from the character of the highs. Not surprising given the rise around 1K in the Stereophile measurements. I was less impressed hearing them the second time. But, I can understand why others may really like them.
For my downstairs I am debating whether to get the Pesrona 9H or the Blades. I also have a 3 year old toddler but I am more concerned with the kid knocking the speaker over. Anyways, that decision will wait until the kid is a little older.
@prof Ok so I went on a bit of an audio tour today. I am going to write up some full impressions on my website soon, sonic visions dot org.
But briefly.
Executive stereo Joseph audio perspective 2 graphene: This was not in an ideal setup it was kind of in a tiled hall way that is very wide, but was impressed with the dynamics, clarity and huge sound for such a small speaker. Sadly dealer not willing to budge from msrp so will pass on these.
Kennedy hifi Sopra 3: Very precise crystalline top end.. kind of reminded me of the precise sound of the persona that I heard at the same dealer. Excellent imaging, separation.
Yamaha NS 5000: Wow. Now bear in mind that it was a huge room they were in but not optimal. Incredible holographic imaging... acoustic images float in the air around you like projections.. the speakers completely disappear, very pure clear yet somehow extremely musically intoxicating sound. Although the sopra 3 was maybe a hair bit more detailed or possibly leaner... the yamaha had the better imaging, more lifelike natural timbre. I am extremely impressed.
smodtactical, I'd enjoy reading a bit more detail on your auditions, impressions of the Joseph speakers and what grabbed you about the Yamahas. I've heard the Yamaha speakers at shows and they were certainly attention grabbing!
I like the Rockport Avior speaker. The current model is a bit out of your price range ($38,000 US), but, older used models might be available. This is a speaker on the warmer side of neutral.
There are Canadian brands that you should be able to audition, such as Gershman, that are pretty nice sounding.
You have a pretty good list of foorstanding speakers you are interested in, and they do span a range of different kinds of sound, so I think you will have a decent idea of what is out there if you can actually audition these speakers. I have a few more suggestions:
ProAc floorstanders with the ribbon tweeter. The bigger models might be a bit too much for your room (they tend to be a bit bass heavy), but, worth an audition because they sound so good.
German Physiks--these speakers use an unconventional bending wave driver that is omni-directional (like MBL) and sound quite good in a room of your size.
Since you have Paradigm’s now, I’m not sure why you’re not considering Personas that have Beryllium - which are completely protected? Short of your children taking a hammer to them, there’s no way to damage the tweeters or midranges. The acoustic PPA Lens covers are made of metal. The difference you’ll hear moving to these over your Signatures will make those sound as if they’re broken.
Here’s the link to the Persona’s configurator where you can build them like any way you choose like building a car online. Good luck in search!
Thanks guys... recently auditioned joseph perspective 2 graphene and yamaha ns5000. Very impressed with both but the NS5000 was the one that really got my attention !
JBL synthesis 4367s. Full sounding, incredibly dynamic and detailed. They sound good with any genre and at any volume level. They have an amazing sound stage and you would think the band in musician are right in front of you. They can go louder than you ever would want without a hint of distortion. Best speakers that I have ever heard.
If you go to Audio Excellence in Toronto to audition expensive gear make sure you dress the part. I’ve had some “interesting” experiences trying to audition stuff here ;-)
If you haven't yet, you might want to go to Audio Excellence in Toronto (
https://www.audioexcellence.ca/) and give an audition to the Wilson Yvette or Sabrina, Sonus Faber with various floor standers in your price range, and Magnepan (if you have the room for large planar magnetic), as well as Legacy and Klipsh. That was just after a quick search for audio shops in Ontario, but I'm sure there are others. You can certainly find online deals with free returns, but given the hassle of shipping back speakers that don't work for you, there's no substitute for hearing them for yourself. Preferably with a home trial for a few days with your room and other components. I was able to arrange that with my dealer and it was worth the $200 charge for delivery and pickup when investing the kind of money you're talking about.
Narrow down your search that way, and possibly reach out to see if there are any local audiophiles that have direct only speakers (e.g., Spatial or others) to try and hear them before you purchase. It's only your ears that matter in the selection, and in particular they have to integrate with your components and room. But enjoy the hunt! It's an enjoyable process.
I just went through a process of choosing new speakers in your price range. To meet your non beryllium requirement I would choose,out of the many good choices listed here, a used pair of Stenheim Alumine 3 or 5 used. There have been pairs of both on Agon recently. They lack for nothing and are quite efficient at 1w/94db. I decided I wanted beryllium and bought a pair of Magico Q3s instead.
Regarding Raidho I would look at Borresen also since they have the former Raidho designer. Still as expensive though, this price range only includes their standmounts.
@smodtactical I’d advise probably Executive Stereo first. I bought mine from Ed and he’s a great guy, and I know he has the Perspectives for audition since I just heard them there myself this week. TIP: Ask to have the Perspective pulled well out from the wall and spread more apart. I find that showroom to be a bit boomy in the bass and if the Perspectives are near the back wall like they were when I heard them this week, they will boom. The Perspectives are capable of very rich but tight bass - I own the original Perspectives. The ones at Executive Stereo are the slightly updated Graphene driver version.
You must have a verified phone number and physical address in order to post in the Audiogon Forums. Please return to Audiogon.com and complete this step. If you have any questions please contact Support.